Amanda Cicchini is being touted as the new “Allison Stokke,” or at least the “Allison Stokke of 2007.”
Don’t get me wrong: the junior soccer standout from the Big East powerhouse University of West Virginia is dead sexy. We’d love to have her come to the COED office in Manhattan for a Miss COED photo shoot, any day of the week…but she’s still no Allison Stokke.
Regardless of my personal feelings on the situation take a look at the Amanda Cicchini and Allison Stokke’s galleries after the jump and VOTE so we can put this issue to bed!






Marisa Miller Victoria's Secret Hotness
Incredible Knockout Punch
If You Like Side Boob…
Sexiest College Cheerleaders
Epic Side Boob
Be A Man! Beer Can Chicken
Should You Lend Money To Friends?
A Sandy Handful
Pokies!
White Face Sammy Sosa
7 Signs Your Lady Crazy
Movie Myths About Sex
World's Hottest MILF
WTF?!
#1 Reason I Love Australia
Hand Bra
Cheryl Tweedy WAG Cleavage
Dozens of Sexy Hometown Hotties
Bubble Butts!
Clingy Shirt + Water = You Know What
Pool Action
She Is Gonna Win!
Hot Rap Video
My Fav Pic of the Day? Yes!
Split!
50 Hottest American Women
The Girls of Summer
Sand Bra
You are crazy- amanda is way hotter.
look at the voting! america has chosen allison… sorry cartman
the poll is stuffed. i go to school with amanda and see her most everyday- way hotter! xStanzyx, YOU PICKED A BAD DAY TO STOP SNIFFING GLUE.
it is agreed – Amanda is RETARDED HOT. Look at that ass???? All the damn 30 yr old white computer Digg geeks are voting for Allison…hands down Amanda is the hottest.
Well, if sluttiness equates to hotness,(not that there’s anything wrong with that) then Amanda wins. But 10 years from now, Amanda’s going to be a balloon, and Allison will still have that super tight bod. Allison wins.
Call 706-886-0928 please!!!
does Amanda like girls?
I call for a ’sex off’ wherein both women make love to each other and the one that can go the longest WINS! Just let me know the time and place so I can make my final judgment…
Who decided that these chicks were the hottest high school athletes? To be honest, almost every high school track or soccer team has at least 3 hot chicks that are just as hot or even hotter that these two girls. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying that they aren’t attractive— I just don’t see how why these particular girls were chosen as hot high school sports chicks, when chicks of this caliber come a dime a dozen ( turn off the computer and go outside, trust me you’ll see them ! =) )
Amanda is a skank. She has hooked with with the entire offensive line of the WVY football team – all at the same time.
ha amanda is no slut i can asure u of that!…cock tease however ill definitely give u that..this girl does not put out like you would think
Allison is even more stunning because she’s not even trying! She’s off the chart.
i like amanda better…smokingggg hotttt
i go to school with amanda this girl is gorgeous!
and on the record far from being a slut
What taste you brothers got ya can’t see Amanda don’t have NOTHING and I mean NOTHING on Allison. Please ya better look again…….
My personal fave is Alison… by 13′10″ lol Amanda is cute, I have to admit….but……
For one Alison is a brunette, not a blonde, my preference, and of course tall and gorgeous! and excels in all she competes in including this comparison, which in my opinion is close, but not close enough. Hands down the ultimate sports hottie!
“If in the jungle two elephants fight lustily, he shall do little who champions either; rather snare both, tame both, ride both, as the charioteer of the Tarot with the opposing sphinxes, black and white.”
=)